So, I was perusing the MLB standings today, intrigued by a Deadspin post claiming that both the Rays and Marlins were in first place. To my surprise, they both were. But then sometime else caught my eye: the AL West.
This division only has 4 teams: Anaheim, Oakland, Seattle, and Texas. The other AL divisions have 5. Basic statistics dictates that AL West teams will make the playoffs more often, on average, than other AL teams. I thought, well, that sucks for the rest of the AL, but I'm sure that the numbers of teams dictate that. Not so fast.
2 NL divisions, the East and the West, also have 5 teams, so fair play there. But the NL Central, home of my lowly Pirates, has 6 teams. You don't need to know multi-variable calculus to know that a transfer of one NL Central team to the AL West (or some reorganization with the same effect but better geographical implications) would balance the equation, making the playoff hunt more fair.
But you can't just switch teams, what with tradition and different rules and all. Well, unless you're the Brewers, who got transfered from the AL to the NL for the 1998 season so the Tigers could move from the AL East to the AL Central, what with the critical expansion of adding the D-Rays and the D-Backs (sadly, though, no mention of the D-bags).
So, why the imbalance? It's hard to make the claim that the two leagues are separate and we can't just switch a team. For one, it's already been done, and with inter-league play it just doesn't seem like as big of a deal anymore. My proposal? Send Houston to the AL West. Travel times are a concern, since the divisions are broken up fairly well geographically. But the Astros already have to travel to Chicago, Pittsburgh, Milwaukee, Cincinatti, and St.Louis, with the latter being by far the closest. In the AL West, they go to Texas (where the already are), Anaheim, Oakland (right next door to Anaheim), and Seattle. Furthermore, it would simplify scheduling and tie-breakers.
Plus, the Pirates would have a better (if still utterly hypothetical) chance of making the playoffs. A big win-win here, I think.
Read More......